For years, one of the major arguments opponents level at the need to switch to alternative energy is its greater cost.

That argument is rapidly losing its support.

Solar PV rapidly becoming the cheapest option to generate electricity

by Kees van der Leun

For a long time, the holy grail of solar photovoltaics (PV) has been “grid parity,” the point at which it would be as cheap to generate one’s own solar electricity as it is to buy electricity from the grid. And that is indeed an important market milestone, being achieved now in many places around the world. But recently it has become clear that PV is set to go beyond grid parity and become the cheapest way to generate electricity.

Whenever I say this I encounter incredulity, even vehement opposition, from friends and foes of renewable energy alike. Apparently, knowledge of the rapid developments of the last few years has not been widely disseminated. But it’s happening, right under our noses! It is essential to understand this so that we can leverage it to rapidly switch to a global energy system fully based on renewable energy.

Solar Cells

Solar cells.A hundred solar cells, good for 380 watts of solar PV power.Photo: Ariane van Dijk

Working on solar PV energy at Ecofys since 1986, I have seen steady progression: efficiency goes up, cost goes down. But it was only on a 2004 visit to Q-Cells‘ solar cell factory in Thalheim, Germany, that it dawned on me that PV could become very cheap indeed. They gave me a stack of 100 silicon solar cells, each capable of producing 3.8 watts of power in full sunshine. I still have it in the office; it’s only an inch high!

That’s when I realized how little silicon was needed to supply the annual electricity consumption of an average European family (4,000 kWh). Under European solar radiation, it would take 1,400 cells, totaling less than 30 pounds of silicon.

Of course, you need to cover the cells with some glass and add a frame, a support structure, some cables, and an inverter. But the fact that 30 pounds of silicon, an amount that costs $700 to produce, is enough to generate a lifetime of household electricity baffled me. Over 25 years, the family would pay at least $25,000 for the same 100,000 kilowatt-hours (kWh) of electricity from fossil fuels — and its generation cost alone would total over $6,000!

At a very large scale, the cost of manufacturing anything drops to just above the cost of its base materials. As scale goes up, per-unit costs come down. This is known as a “learning curve” — the price per unit of capacity comes down by x percent for every doubling of cumulatively installed capacity. For solar PV modules, the learning rate has been exceptionally high, averaging 22 percent for the past two decades. The cost of the “balance of system,” i.e., all other components needed, follows this trend line closely. So this is what we see happening now in PV:

PV Learning Curve

Learning curve for silicon-based solar PV modules. Note the logarithmic scales. Colored lines represent various technologies.Image: Wim Sinke, ECN. Sources: Navigant Consulting, EPIA

To unleash the power of a steep learning curve, you need a market driver when costs are still high; we should all be grateful to Germany for playing that role since the introduction of a feed-in tariff there in the year 2000.

Under the German renewable energy scheme, a family or company investing in a solar PV system receives a fixed amount per kWh of solar electricity supplied to the grid. The additional costs are distributed over all users of the grid, nationwide. Successive governments, in varying coalitions, have kept the principle alive, continuously lowering the tariffs as scale went up and cost came down. Contrary to what some believe, competition on the German PV market has always been fierce, which of course is a driving factor behind the ensuing cost (and price) reductions.

In 2004, the feed-in tariff was $0.77 per kWh. For 2012, the tariff for large, ground-based systems is already down to $0.23 per kWh, in spite of eight years of inflation. Expectations are that, even at this low tariff, between 3,500 and 5,000 megawatts of new PV capacity will be installed in Germany next year. This means that the PV supply chain and investors can earn a living at $0.23 per kWh, including operation and maintenance cost, margins, and return on capital.

But that’s in Germany. The funny thing is: Germany is not very sunny! Average annual solar radiation in the sunniest parts of the country, where most PV systems are installed, is 1,000 to 1,100 kWh per 10.8 square feet, measured on a horizontal plane. The world map below shows that this is substantially less than in most of the world. In a sunnier region, like the southwestern U.S., solar radiation is double Germany’s, so the same installed capacity (in watts) will produce twice as much solar electricity (in kWh). As a consequence, the cost of a solar PV kWh in Arizona is only half of the cost in Germany, i.e., already below $0.12. That’s right now, without any subsidies or tax breaks.

Solar Irradiation Map

Solar radiation map of the world.Image: Meteotest

But what of the competition? Aside from PV, the bulk of new power plants these days are either natural gas-fired, coal-fired, or wind energy. Nuclear is a would-be competitor, but so little of it has been built in recent decades that real cost data are scarce; the trend seems to be sharply up, however, and little is known about the cost of additional post-Fukushima safety measures.

Costs vary per country, and fossil fuels mostly don’t get the right costs allocated for their CO2 emissions, but let’s take two recent studies for the U.S. here. The Brattle Group published the Connecticut Integrated Resource Plan [PDF] in 2008. They found levelized cost per kWh for natural gas-fired power plants to be $0.076 to $0.092, and for coal, $0.086, both without carbon capture and storage. And in 2009, MIT issued its Update on the Cost of Nuclear Power [PDF], in which they found levelized cost per kWh for nuclear’s competitors of $0.062 (coal) and $0.065 (natural gas), without any charge for CO2 emissions.

The cost of wind energy is already close to competitive with gas and coal. The recent Global Status Report [PDF] by REN21 states its kWh-cost for suitable locations as $0.05 to $0.09, for an average of $0.07. Wind power cost is still decreasing, due to learning effects, but at a much lower rate than the cost of PV.

It is highly unlikely that fossil fuels will get away without any charge for CO2 emissions in the long run. In a growing number of countries, such as the 27 countries of the European Union and Australia, this market distortion has already (mostly) come to an end. But let’s assume that the cost of solar PV electricity needs to drop to below $0.06 per kWh to live up to the claim that it’s the cheapest source of electricity. In sunny regions, we will need to halve the cost of PV power again to make that happen. Three doublings of cumulative capacity will do, since, according to PV’s rapid learning curve, every doubling of capacity leads to a cost reduction of 22 percent. After three doublings the cost will be multiplied by 0.78 * 0.78 * 0.78 = 0.47.

Cumulative installed PV capacity globally was 40 gigawatts (GW) at the end of last year. Three doublings mean this has to grow by a factor of eight, to 320 GW, to achieve the necessary halving of cost. From 2005 to 2010, PV capacity installed annually grew by an average of 49 percent per year. Even if this slows down to 25 percent per year in the near future, we will reach 320 GW in 2018 — that’s only seven years from now!

To be sure, that was starting from a present PV kWh cost of $0.12, valid for sunny regions like the Southwest U.S. As can be seen from the solar map above, the regions with at least comparable solar radiation include most of Latin America, Africa, the Middle East, Australia, and large swaths of Asia, including all of India. For all those regions, PV will be the cheapest option by 2018. After that, further increases in cumulatively installed capacity will drive PV cost further down, making it grow swiftly in the regions in which it is the cheapest option to generate electricity.

This development does not, in itself, make life easy. Developing a world energy system that runs on 100 percent renewable energy by 2050 is a major and complex global effort, involving large investments in energy efficiency, renewable energy, and infrastructure, as we have shown in “The Energy Report” [PDF]. But it sure helps a lot! Kees van der Leun has an M.Sc. in physics from Utrecht University. In 1986, he joined Ecofys as its third employee. Ecofys is an international consultancy specialized in energy efficiency, renewable energy, and climate change. At present, he is its COO.

Original post on grist.org

36 Responses to “Solar Power Is Economical”

  1. It’s just frustrating when I’ve been working on alternative energy stories since the early 90’s and today’s “leaders” don’t get it

  2. nice. it is very adictive. i with one panel from autozone i remember it came with a 7amp charge controller.i was wondering how do the home made wind turbine compare to the windmax money wise and power wise.

  3. I figure once you get confident with these broken solar panels, and if you had multiple types with multiple colour shades you could getting with them creating mosaics in the Roman style. 🙂

  4. arbracott says:

    How to make a solar power windmill: The dependence on conventional energy sources is too much that this is a tim…

  5. asmitrzmer folla says:

    Every Little Helps – Wasted Kinetic Energy into Electricity
    OilPrice.com
    Humanity is constantly looking at innovative technologies to help reduce our dependence on fossil fuels. Yet it’s not always the big discoveries that make the difference. Small inventions that reduce our dependence gradually can also have significant …

  6. Earlier this week the National Post published a merciless editorial on Ontario’s energy policies under Premier Dalton McGuinty. The editorial came on the heels of an Auditor-General’s described by the editorial board as one of the “most scathing indictments of government mismanagement we have ever witnessed.” Anyone who has been following the McGuinty government’s reckless embrace of so-called alternative energy sources and its early fervour for windmills, the multi-billion dollar deal it cut with a South Korean manufacturer of windmills and solar panels, will have no trouble accepting the terms of auditor’s or the Post ’s equally searing editorial. It is and was a sad tale, a jumble of highly expensive initiatives, pushed without the proper study and foresight by the Premier himself, bypassing all logic either of commerce or of energy supply.

  7. Today Reviews Best Offer – Instapark® MPPT-60 MPPT 60 Amp Solar Power Charge Controller, 900 Watt at 12V / 1,800 Watt at 24V –

  8. aris rafter says:

    The major bonus I see to wind is that it can be repaired when it fails and solar most likely will need to be replaced.

  9. hagensidet says:

    More Alternative Energy, Says UN Chief at Energy Summit …: The UN has declared 2012 the International Year of …

  10. BuyNew Casio Men’s PAW5000-1 Pathfinder Solar Power Blue Dial Watch Buy Compare Price Bestseller Shops Discount Tools Auto Industry Outdoors Home-Garden –

  11. rouse swellisk says:

    Tips on How to Go Solar: Via Easy Solar FinancingSwitching to alternative energy such as solar is one of the bes…

  12. jard gras says:

    The gas prices have nearly doubled since Obama has been in office, and he doesn’t care because he wants us to turn to alternative energy

  13. jess saitl says:

    A question that many Canadians are wondering: there is so much skepticism about solar power- not enough sunlight, not enough energy…

  14. heinbland mese says:

    Los Angeles Times

    Oped: LA shows that solar power isn’t just for the wealthy
    Long Beach Press-Telegram
    For too long, however, working-class neighborhoods and communities of color have been left out and left behind when it comes to building a healthier, more sustainable Los Angeles for ourselves and for future generations. Solar power is a case in point.
    Cloudy skies for LA’s solar Angeles Times
    all 26 news articles »

  15. kleisson ming says:

    LA Can Generate 5 GW of Solar Power Using No Additional Land …: Due to the fact that rooftop solar s…

  16. nassis rajax says:

    NAIT fills green tech knowledge gap
    Edmonton Journal
    The 22-year-old former rig worker from rural Bashaw is enrolled in the Alternative Energy Program at NAIT, a polytechnic school in Edmonton. “I think there’s going to be a huge future in alternative energy as technology develops,” says Kasur.

  17. had we chosen alternative energy over oil, City would be relegated and Chelsea would be in mid table. More wind mills please

  18. sarikinski mair says:

    Some guy knocked at my door this morning and asked me if I’d consider an alternative energy supplier. I said, “No,im quite happy with food”

  19. 16.4 of the $20.5 billion in loans granted went 2 companies either run by or primarily owned by Obama financial backers

  20. piuse petromborg says:

    The solar power unit pins production hopes on crowd-funding It took Deep Thought (the supercomputer from The Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy)… –

  21. napp helman says:

    SunVolt Solar Power Station aims to speed up solar charging of mobile …
    CNET
    Don Cayelli says one of his main motivations for developing his SunVolt Solar Power Station was that he couldn’t find a solar charger that worked well for charging his iPad on his boat. He sails a lot and uses his iPad as a plotter and …
    New Project Offers Game Changing Green Magazine
    all 2 news articles »

  22. U.S. Oil And Gas Put Squeeze On Alternative Energy: During the run up to mid-$4 gas and $147 a barrel oil in 200…

  23. Dear Friends, A Seminar was organized today at the Indian Social Institute (Lodi Road, New Delhi) on the theme India’s Power Crisis and Nuclear Energy: Avoiding Power Black-outs, Avoiding False Solutions Chaired by Gen V K Singh (Retd.), the seminar was addressed by prominent on energy policy and climate change – Shankar Sharma, Soumya Dutta, Praful Bidwai, M G Devasahayam, Manish Ram and Neeraj Jain. The nuclear lobby has cynically exploited the energy crisis in India, as was witnessed during the recent power black-outs, to push its case for yet more atomic power, regardless of appropriateness, safety, environmental soundness, and costs. The panelists in the seminar today critically examined these arguments in the light of experience, and discussed an alternative energy perspective for the country based on the principles of efficiency, sustainability, equitable energy, and decentralised energy system. The obsession with GDP and growth has been behind the plans to expand the…

  24. seon levenemont says:

    GOP spins so fast on their policy & legislation stances we should harness them all for alternative energy sou …

  25. ilkoon mcclury says:

    (TrendHunter.com) Ping-Yi Lin’s Chewing Gum Battery concept is perfect for those who just can’t seem to keep their battery full. This ingenious concept serves up solar power strips designed to…

  26. First Solar, Kiran Energy, Mahindra to bring 50 MW of solar power to India: New Delhi, October 8, 2012 First S…

  27. buschradze untley says:

    Obama has wasted billions in failed & corrupt alternative energy companies yet he continues to tout this as an “investment”.

  28. Solar power is now cheaper than diesel generators – The Express Tribune: The Express TribuneSolar power is now c… …

  29. Diy Solar Power Guide To Living Off The Grid – 5 Solar Years: This Easy To Understand Ebook Has Instructions, Wi…

  30. keong willie says:

    You’re on the content marketing highway chugging along hoping to be valuable, but the gas gauge tank points to E. Now what?I propose it’s time you think outside the Chevron. Here are 12 sources of alternative energy that has may help fuel your trek going forward.

  31. fazizahn wechnerles says:

    Just vacuumed. With the amount of hair me and my critters produce in a week, we could probably heat our house. Alternative energy?

  32. lan hansendier says:

    Make Money In The Energy Niche! Solar Panels And Wind-mills!
    Easy Energy Provides A Simple Solution For Those Wanting To Go Green And Save Electricity And Heating Bills Using Solar And Wind Alternative Energy! Affiliates Go To For Resources!

  33. Chancellor Merkel’s government has occupied the term Energiewende (clean energy transition) and made it its own, as if it had coined the moniker in the first place. In fact, its origins go back deep into West Germany’s mass movements and ultimately have their source in the United States, during the alternative energy boom of the 1970s.

  34. stamanson devissel says:

    New Finds that Solar Power Could Serve All of the World’s …: A new issued by the World Wildlife …

  35. raigherfie says:

    Damn lmao US was and is still trying hard to get rid of Chavez to get some cheaper oil. Damn just use alternative energy oil runs out.

  36. waring bob says:

    I oppose everything the enviro-nazis do- why must the coal industry be destroyed for the sake of alternative energy? why not have ALL?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *