Personally, I don’t think it’s an either-or choice.

First of all, there is a great deal of money and employment avaialble in the green energy field.

Secondly, if we despoil the planet completely, money will no longer be available at all, there may be no people to use it anyway, and we’ll ask ourselves why we prioritized a short-term, arbitrary construct like money over our very survival.

Nevertheless, John Fullerton does a great job outlining the challenges.

The big choice: money or planet?

by John Fullerton

There is an alternative to the choice between ecological disaster and economic destruction. But we need efforts that go beyond CSR, an unprecedented commitment and shared sacrifice.

The big choice: economic destruction or ecological destruction?

A $20tn (£12.7tn) “externality” presents civilisation with a big choice: economic destruction or ecological destruction, both with chilling global security implications. It’s a big challenge, but one we can solve.

The Carbon Tracker Initiative recently released an illuminating report, Unburnable carbon – are the world’s financial markets carrying a carbon bubble? It addresses the role that the value of corporate managed oil, gas, and coal reserves will play on the climate crisis and visa versa.

What the report does not make explicit is the apparent big choice: either we must absorb a $20tn write-off into our already stressed global economy over the next decade, or we will implicitly accept civilisation-transforming climate change.

The report details three salient facts: in order to reduce the risk of exceeding two degrees celsius warming to a 20% chance, our carbon-burning budget for the next 40 years is 565 GtC02. Total proved fossil fuel reserves are estimated at 2795 GtC02, nearly five times the remaining budget, implying 80% of these reserves should be left in the ground. Seventy-four percent of these reserves are state owned, while 26% is owned by the 100 largest listed coal companies and 100 largest listed oil and gas companies.

From the market value of the public companies, we can extrapolate the total estimated market value of these reserves to be $27tn (£17tn).

A cap on carbon emissions designed to limit warming to two degrees will mean sovereign states and public corporations must strand 80% of their $27tn of proved reserves and related assets, a loss exceeding $20tn.

If we incur a write-off of this magnitude, the risk that our fragile and interconnected global economy would collapse is high.

Fossil fuel intensive economies and investors would be severely damaged, triggering a deep and prolonged recession. Some nations, like Saudi Arabia where energy represents 75% of government revenues, and Venezuela (50% of government revenues), would face economic devastation leading to widespread social unrest.

The markets are ignoring this risk today, as the Carbon Tracker report makes clear. They have been given no reason to do otherwise — the US House of Representatives recently defeated a resolution which simply said “climate change is occurring, is caused largely by human activities, and poses significant risks for public health and welfare.” It is no wonder that American Electric Power announced that it is shelving plans for the nation’s most prominent coal-plant-directed carbon sequestration initiative until economic and policy conditions create a viable path forward.

Rising fossil fuel stock prices indicate that the markets assume we will blow past the 2 degree warming limit without blinking, while scientists estimate that three billion people will lose access to fresh water at four degrees warming. Were private and government investment in sequestration technologies of a scale that mattered and tangible signs of revolutionary progress in those technologies evident, one could conclude the market is not predicting ecological destruction.

However, neither is the case, and in fact the promise of carbon sequestration technology fix is diminishing as reality sets in.

There is an alternative to the big choice between ecological destruction and economic destruction, but it is not simply hopeful corporate social responsibility programmes and growing the green economy. A viable plan will entail real costs, unprecedented commitment, and shared sacrifice.

Many economic models seek to estimate the cost of climate change mitigation, often concluding the costs are trivial in comparison to the costs of inaction. If such models focus on aggressively limiting carbon to 350 parts per million as the science now demands without presuming carbon sequestration will solve the stranded asset problem entirely, the predictable costs get quite scary.

The portion of the $20tn cost potential that will be written off depends upon unknowable developments in carbon sequestration technology. Prudence suggests that we should plan on incurring at least half of this potential loss, and get serious about developing and implementing policies to limit carbon pollution. The choice of burning Russian sovereign coal or Exxon shareholder oil presents complex political, financial, social, and security challenges.

Mitigating the unpleasant consequences boils down to a macro capital allocation decision. We must of course invest aggressively in clean technologies of all kinds. At the same time, we must accelerate and scale up the tremendous potential of low technology paths — like avoided deforestation and grassland restoration — to sequester carbon.

We must also, though, remove subsides and divest from our destructive fossil fuel based energy, transportation, and industrial agriculture systems, and from the destabilising and counterproductive speculation of the Wall Street financial system. We must choose to scale back our Cold War military infrastructure and wasteful government “bridges to nowhere”. The energy system transition demands a truly unprecedented, focused commitment of private and public investment resources and public policy that supports it.

It’s time for true leadership from the richest half billion people whose consumption and investment decisions will determine the fate of civilisation. It’s time we awaken to the burden we bear.

John Fullerton is founder and president of the Capital Institute

Original post on The Guardian

41 Responses to “Money or Survivial?”

  1. actually has few nuclear weapons then we do. That is why they didnt have to cut down or destroy any under the new treaty

  2. cher star says:

    David Rose is notorious and fabricating data to claim that global warming isn’t happening as well as for fabricating quotes, so this story in the Daily Mail comes as no surprise. Rose presents a graph of temperatures from BEST that to prove that global warming has stopped and then quotes Judith Curry

    “As for the graph disseminated to the media, she said: ‘This is “hide the decline” stuff. Our data show the pause, just as the other sets of data do. Muller is hiding the decline.
    Read the rest of this post… | Read the comments on this post…
    Also check out the featured ScienceBlog of the week: Inside the Outbreaks on the ScienceBlogs Book Club

  3. krometoade says:

    Global Climate Change and Response of Carbon Cycle in the Equatorial Pacific and Indian Oceans and Adjacent Landmasses, Volume 73 (Elsevier Oceanography Series) Download PDF –

  4. delairschh says:

    Interesting video. My name is Laura, and I am offering a global salvation plan to anyone that breaths oxygen. Please visit my site ccrg dot info to learn more. Blessings & Prosperity

  5. wilton leodon says:

    Mumbai-like deluge redux every 5 years?: Times of India Cloud bursts, such as the one that deluged Mumbai in …

  6. ferr santarson says:

    (AP) — Heat-trapping greenhouse gases in the atmosphere are building up so high, so fast, that some scientists now think the world can no longer limit global warming to the level world leaders have agreed upon as safe.

  7. ok the reason i got scared was that my stupid fan fell behind me while the music was right near the end!!! T.T

  8. asilago fie says:

    as a gardener i can assure you its no good to give your plants too much “plant food” omg my brain typing this. MORONS.

  9. elk azingtonel says:

    We can be and can be to think about it…………the world is filled with />very country they are better than the other one.

  10. churlo nawi says:

    Back from the Surin Islands Nat Park. Beautiful place – shame most of the Coral has been annihilated by tsunami/global warming/fishing?

  11. erbe kazu says:

    Kind of ridiculous that they do not stock paper bags at the self checkouts. Heard of global climate change suburbs?!

  12. mats rich says:

    You want to be careful of sheltering yourself in college. If you want a greater and feel for the real world, which eventually get anyway, want a city campus like NYU. But if you really, really want a strong campus community NYU might end up being too open for you.

  13. lizawadhu arnara says:

    i think the two movies that had to deal with davy jones was the best because davy jones was a great character in this movie and i dont think they could have made him any better because it was just that great

  14. Little Emily (Kindle Edition)
    By Jack Hughes

    Buy new: $2.99

    First tagged “religion” by Peter Joseph Lewis
    Customer tags: fairytale, tragedy, religion, god, fairies, fairy, nature, angel, historical fiction, religion and spirituality, angels, death

  15. whitsu mell says:

    Is there Katyusha / Sacred War song/ Farewell Slavankia version play by andre rieu?? these are also the best song….

  16. Flight operations assistant needed in Mojave, CA for exciting and fast paced environment! Work with a “Top Gun” team! Send me your

  17. sie dori says:

    I have the advantage that I helped set up before it got sold to Reed and before it got spun off – from a tech and ebusiness perspective back then but I learned lots about the business, since I knew much about wine anyway, so I know people who can help me for PR and all 🙂 Getting excited now, something’s bound to go wrong and make it not happen 🙁

  18. Know your place. Stay N your lane. Work your environment. B accountable.
    Empower your team. Lose the pride. Keep it fresh. #SimpleRules

  19. winsenhara gerwigers says:

    Nature Photography Photo Workshop (Kindle Edition)
    By Nat Coalson

    Buy new: $15.86
    Customer Rating:

    First tagged “kindle” by Allen
    Customer tags: photography(2), nature photography kindle, landscape photography, nature photography, lightroom, kindle, photography book, photo workshop, kindle photography book, nat coalson

  20. verster says:

    It is time the world addresses the Global Climate Change from pure spiritual angle rather than following it from physical perspective.

  21. berger sarte says:

    Aerosmith’s summer tour is called “The Global Warming Tour” and ends with each of them melting and killing polar bears Aug 8 in Tacoma, WA.

  22. iwalski krzywick says:

    Gases that damage the ozone layer are mostly out of use in air-conditioning, but replacements used in developing countries are potent agents of global warming.

  23. downlouce says:

    Team of say such an increase would cause severe droughts and see millions of migrants seeking refuge The hellish vision of a world warmed by 4C within a lifetime has been set out by an international team of scientists, who say the glacial progress of the global climate change talks that in Mexico today makes the so-called safe limit of 2C impossible to keep. A 4C rise in the planet’s temperature would see severe droughts across the world and millions of migrants seeking refuge as their food supplies collapse. “There is now little to no chance of maintaining the rise in global surface temperature at below 2C, despite repeated high-level statements to the contrary,” said Kevin Anderson, at the University of Manchester, who with colleague Alice Bows contributed research to a special collection of Royal Society journal papers published tomorrowtoday. “Moreover, the impacts associated with 2C have been revised upwards so that 2C now represents the threshold [of] extremely…

  24. malkennamo says:

    Derek Muller is the Creative Director of Veritasium, a science video blog with 90 films based off of interviews with Australians about issues such as global warming, seasons and the scale of the universe.

  25. campaign jobs summer jobs human rights civil rights lgbt lgbtq rights nonprofit work jobs equality inequality progressive work progressive jobs progressive causes work for change change campaign student jobs college student jobs college jobs legal la […]

  26. blach jarvatter says:

    This is the first study to show a direct correlation between global climate change and the emergence of Vibrio diseases

  27. Former skeptic now says world warmed 2.5 F since 1750, 1.5 F since 1960, “Humans are almost entirely the cause.”

  28. menidani thosfel says:

    Whilst the is controversial here, at least Aus has had the courage to take on the global climate change issue

  29. @GOP

  30. is proud to offer the Salomon – Speedcross 3 (Aluminium/Autobahn/Rubis-X) – Footwear: Light and ready to ride. Get ready to blaze trails in the Speedcross 3 from Salomon. ; Update to the Speedcross 2, ; Anti-debris mesh upper. ; Water-resistant, synthetic upper materials help keep feet dry. ; Sensifit technology ensures an enhanced, snug fit. ; Quicklace system allows for a secure, customized fit. ; Lace pockets keeps laces tucked away. ; Protective rubber toe cap. ; Soft, synthetic linings for a great step-in feel. ; insole offers underfoot and features moisture-managing for a cooler, drier environment. ; Dual-density EVA midsole for supreme cushioning. ; Midsole Heel/Toe Height: 19mm/10mm. ; Mud Snow Contagrip, non-marking rubber outsole, is especially designed to provide exceptional grip and durability in winter conditions. ; Aggressive lug pattern for optimal traction. ; Weight: 11 oz ; Product measurements were taken using size…

  31. 60+ degrees on Thanksgiving? Thinking this global warming is just fine with me! Way better than a snow or ice storm!

  32. grungleddy emperarkin says:

    The Revolutionary “cookbook” Style – Your Digital Learning Curve. Only A Genuine Pro Knows All The Techniques – Esther Beaton Shares Her Career Secrets To Help You Create Timeless Winners. 60 Top Techniques For Shooting Salable Stock Photos.

  33. lorenna josloway says:

    DES MOINES, Iowa — This year’s drought is consistent with predictions that global climate change would bring about weather extremes including more frequent droughts, said a released Monday.

  34. My name is Aimee Nester and I own Aimee’s Kid Ranch. Where we wrangle fun, creativity and learning together! We are a listed child care that offers affordable, high quality care in a “farm” environment. We have wonderful advantages over child care […]

  35. POSITION: Electrical Qualifying Supervisor (Warehouse / Industrial Environment) LOCATION: Based in South Yorkshire but role will involve covering sites in Central England – from South Birmingham up to Yorkshire and all in between, including….

  36. Download here Clarissa W. Confer
    History. MNH | The Marshfield News-Herald | The series — through stories,. Daily Life in Pre-Columbian Native America. ABC-CLIO – Product – Daily Life in Pre-Columbian Native America. The Greenwood Press Daily Life Through History Series What. Greenwood Press. Subscriber exclusive Top 5 daily email newsletter Nature and the Environment in Pre-Columbian American Life. Series: The Greenwood Press Daily Life Through History Series. (The Greenwood Press Daily Life Through History Series:. from the era of Native American settlement to modern times. The American Red Cross is assisting with the emergency needs of the. Cover. ABC-CLIO – Series – The Greenwood Press Daily Life Through History. Daily Life in Pre-Columbian Native America by Clarissa. Nonfiction > History; Paleo-Indians; America; Native. The Greenwood Press Daily Life Through History Series Daily Life in Pre-Columbian Native America by Clarissa W Confer

  37. We need to redefine seasons in light of global climate change. No, I’m not a scientist, but I can SEE the bright shiny sun outside

  38. This story should remind all of us that air pollution controls are not just about addressing global warming. They also help us have cleaner air and fewer health problems resulting from smog and haze. earlier this month, Beijing, China having worse than normal air pollution issues. On Jan 14, 2013 the US Embassy’s air pollution sensors in Beijing found the density of the most dangerous small air PM 2.5, at 291 micrograms per cubic meter of air. The world Health Organization’s guidelines for air pollution state that PM 2.5 above 25 micrograms per cubic meter of air is dangerous to a person’s health.To put the problem into perspective for anyone not living in Cloud City….. I mean Beijing, NASA has released two orbital photos of Beijing showing a before and during photo of the air pollution. The photo from Jan 4 shows of the Beijing still visible from space. The photo from Jan 14 shows nothing but a huge, thick cloud of haze with no buildings visible.

  39. laharduino says:

    man I love the pack but u sound like a dumb meathead here, it’s called global climate change, and it is proven to be happening

  40. The demise of the world’s forests some 250 million years ago likely was accelerated by aggressive tree-killing fungi triggered by global climate change, according to a new study by a University of California, Berkeley, scientist and her Dutch and British colleagues.

  41. gie wubb says:

    The last of the bought-off scumbags that told lies about man-made global climate change and global warming have switched sides –

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *