Ever since 9/11, the US’s domestic surveillance program has mushroomed. While there is no doubt that certain groups aim to harm people in the US, I believe we’ve moved a long way down a dangerous path in our fear of attack.

Once essential civil liberties are lost, regaining them is an enormously difficult, if not impossible task.

And now domestic surveillance has become so accepted that agencies engaging in this practice don’t even bother to deny or hide that they are doing it.

Report: FBI to Bring Lockheed Martin’s Facial Recognition Technology Nationwide

by Carl Franzen

The FBI plans to bring facial recognition technology nationwide in 2014 to help law enforcement agencies throughout the U.S. to identify persons of interest, according to FBI sources, Nextgov reported.

The system will let agents upload photos or screen captures of unidentified persons of interest into a computer that will display the closest matches from a database of 10 million mug shots, according to Nextgov.

The system, which will begin testing in Michigan, Washington, Florida and North Carolina this winter, according to Nextgov, is just one component of the FBI’s so-called Next Generation Identification (NGI) effort, a $1 billion program contract awarded to Lockheed Martin in 2008 to radically upgrade the FBI’s fingerprints database, and to augment it with new biometrics information, including iris scans, voice recordings, palm prints and other detailed personal identification markers.

The FBI is surprisingly open about its plans to pursue this system, which it says it needs to complete to speed up the current “ten-print” fingerprint submissions system from “two hours to about 10 minutes on average,” ideally, hypothetically allowing agents to catch everyone ranging from roadside bombers in Iraq to masked bank robbers and child pornography suspects in the U.S.

The agency describes its plans in a fair amount of detail on the FBI website and in a publicly available presentation PDF.

Indeed, Nextgov’s, primary source is Nick Megna, a unit chief at the FBI’s criminal justice information services division. As the website reported in an article posted Friday:

Today, an agent would have to already know the name of an individual to pull up the suspect’s mug shot from among the 10 million shots stored in the bureau’s existing Integrated Automated Fingerprint Identification System. Using the new Next-Generation Identification system that is under development, law enforcement analysts will be able to upload a photo of an unknown person; choose a desired number of results from two to 50 mug shots; and, within 15 minutes, receive identified mugs to inspect for potential matches.

Slightly less forthcoming about the program is defense contractor Lockheed Martin. In an email to TPM, a Lockheed spokesperson confirmed that the Nextgov report accurately described NGI, noting that it is one of several companies working on the program, including Accenture, Global Science & Technology (GST), Innovative Management & Technology Services (IMTS), and MorphoTrak.

As the spokesperson wrote:

“NGI is a state-of-the-art biometric identification system that the FBI and law enforcement agencies are using to help keep Americans and their families safe…In addition to vastly improving the FBI’s fingerprint identification services, NGI will also provide identification capabilities associated with latent and rolled fingerprints, palm prints, and facial recognition. The NGI program also calls for a pilot study to assess iris identification capabilities…

NGI’s fingerprint identification capabilities went live earlier this year. We are making steady progress on the remaining portions of the system, and are developing NGI with a high degree of technical flexibility so that other biometric modalities can be incorporated in the future, if desired.”

In a March press release from the FBI announcing the initial operating ability of the new fingerprints system, which Lockheed Martin referred to TPM, the FBI said: “NGI provides automated fingerprint and latent search capabilities, electronic image storage, and electronic exchange of fingerprints to more than 18,000 law enforcement agencies and other authorized criminal justice partners 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. Upon completion, NGI will have the ability to process fingerprint transactions more effectively and accurately.”

Lockheed refused to provide the name of the facial recognition pilot program, but did reveal that there are several test activities “being implemented by the FBI independently of Lockheed Martin.”

Lockheed also would not confirm whether or not the facial recognition program would incorporate any 3D facial recognition from Animetrics, a New Hampshire-based company. In September 2010, Animetrics and Lockheed Martin were was awarded a U.S. government contract to “improve facial recognition accuracy.” (Animetrics is also behind an iPhone app that matches users to their celebrity likenesses, which has received mediocre ratings from users. “Saw this app is featured for law enforcement. Yea, good luck with that,” wrote one disgruntled user.)

As the blog Network World states: “Each piece of the FBI system ties together into a fairly alarming service for massive surveillance, identification and tracking.”

TPM has contacted the FBI and Animetrics about the NGI program and will update when we receive a response.

But it is also worth noting that several other major companies are working on similar technology, including Google and Facebook. The Atlantic recently investigated the work of PittPatt, a facial recognition software startup founded by alumni of Carnegie Mellon University’s Heinz College and acquired by Google in July. Facebook’s new facial recognition photo-tagging suggestion software was effectively outlawed by the German government in August, with the company being forced to delete already-collected data or face fines.

And yet, the technology itself may not be very effective at identifying people in the first place: A study of facial recognition technology commissioned by the Defense Department in 2010 found that despite being more accurate at identifying faces than humans, computer programs still exhibited “other-race effect,” that is, they experienced difficulty in correctly distinguishing individuals of races outside of those that predominated in the country where the software was developed.

“The [U.S.] government is interested in spotting people who might pose a danger. But they also don’t want to have too many false alarms and detain people who are not real risks.” Alice O’Toole, a professor in The University of Texas at Dallas’ School of Behavioral and Brain Sciences and the lead investigator of the study, told the blog Space War back in September 2010.

Original post on talkingpointsmemo.com

40 Responses to “Facial Recognition and the FBI”

  1. If you believe in heaven and hell, and you preach about how Hollywood is satanic, I can only assume Christian.

  2. Two big names in the Civil Rights mvmt: MLK and Malcolm X. The latter was not letting his ass be passively brutalized.

  3. Since the war on error all supposed terrorist attacks were always said to be done by Al Qaeda. But recently the no-shame stream media now refer to them as Al Qaada style or type, & even Al Qaeda influenced or affiliated. If the IRA blew up a bomb here in the UK the media would probably say they were using Al Qaeda tactics.

  4. And how many of those people who were waterboarded made up information just to stop being The reason why should not be allowed is because the information is NOT accurate. bet there were actually NO lives saved from the waterboarding itself. Any information that came from the either came before or long after. If you honestly have any info, but I think you do, do you think stop you because you keep saying “I know”?

  5. dumali chickel says:

    Seminar held on ‘Human Rights and Oriental Tradition’ Human Rights Association, Bihar, organised a seminar on “Human Rights and Oriental Tradition” at Gandhi… –

  6. Severe Civil rights crimes are committed in Canada by authorities against citizens who try to use their constitutional civil right of not talking to them. This anti-democracy, authority attacks happen with lazer/tazer type guns which work through concrete walls of your home from outside or even the floor above. They rape women with these high power guns, also abuse their access to high ranking officials giving them one side of false story against citizen who questions their abuse of power.

  7. katanaga puge says:

    lo que hizo el che no era una guerra… era una revolucion, y no era un heroe, era un lider.

  8. They knew– persons of African descent struggled and even rebelled openly for freedom from the moment they reached our shores–along with Indians, Irish and German indentured servants when people were unfair. Rebellion and escaping to live in the West or with Indians or to Canada was the best they could do. Brother Malcolm and Doctor King inherited a tradition of civil struggle, the sixties was the right time for people to listen because everyone could see.

  9. We give them money to take advantage of them, it doesn’t take away from the fact that their religion is backwards.

  10. I love how you have a passion for improving human rights and animal rights. I always look up petitions you post on here!

  11. shardahlbo says:

    Reaping The Vote: NY Marriage Equality Rake In Donations
    Lez Get Real
    According to Brian Ellner, a senior strategist for the Human Rights Campaign “It was essential to send a clear signal around the country that we will those who equality, irrespective of We were able to win marriage in New York …
    and more »

  12. Dare I say I didn’t like the book? Read it because a relative wouldn’t shut up about it until I did. It’s not terrible by any stretch but I struggled with what seemed to me like a fairly simplistic view of things – though maybe that was the point? When I finished it (a couple of months ago) I went on good reads to see what others had said and I couldn’t help but be struck by the fact that on the first 5 or 6 pages of reviews (I admit I didn’t look at the hundreds of pages) of all the people who rated it highly (and they were the majority) I noticed one black person. I know not everyone on GR has a photo – but about half did and all but one was white. Which is a symptom of what made me about the book – it felt a little too much like a white person pretending they understand being on the receiving end of racism. I don’t doubt the author’s motives or sincerity, I just think there are some stories some people can’t (or shouldn’t) tell. .

  13. Sorry, but I voted against Obama because I did not believe he was the Most Merciful Messiah like you do. I voted for McCain so Palin could get a decent chance in to give the Repubs some time).

  14. pachner baranton says:

    io ho 30 anni e vivo con mia madre. non siamo ricchi, ma non trovo lavoro, quindi l’alternativa è andare a vivere su un marciapiede e mangiare alla caritas. e se avessi potuto andare via dalla sardegna per lavorare l’avrei già fatto, non lo faccio per svariate (pesanti e irrisolvibili) motivazioni. in che fascia mi colloco?

  15. They can’t extradite these terrorists because of breaching their human rights? As far as I’m concerned they aren’t humans, kill’em.

  16. di courth prelle says:

    Catholic Culture

    US diplomacy arranged a precarious future for Chen Guangcheng
    Catholic Culture
    By Phil Lawler (bio – – send a comment) | May 02, 2012 5:36 PM When the Chinese human-rights activists Chen Guangcheng left the US embassy in Beijing, where he has sought refuge after a dramatic escape from house arrest, American officials …
    and more »

  17. sch pedrichi says:

    What European governments are doing to good human beeings and how they treats human rights, its an utter disgrace & core rotten hypocrisy !

  18. rontrippel says:

    Daily Mail

    MIT’s computer algorithms can tell why you’re smiling better than a human can
    The Verge
    By Bryan Bishop on May 26, 2012 10:24 am 1Comments While some recent studies have found that investment in facial recognition technologies hasn’t yet yielded great success, researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology continue to move the …
    Is that smile real or fake?MIT News
    Can you tell a fake smile from a real one? Research lab’s computer is better …Daily Mail
    What It Means That Computers Can Tell These Smiles But You Can’tThe Atlantic
    Wired.co.uk -Telegraph.co.uk -Mashable
    all 54 news articles »

  19. jkutchnows says:

    In Russia and Ukraine homophobia is rising. To talk about human rights in Eastern Europe means – to talk also about this. No more, no less.

  20. I hate it when super stalkers use satellite facial recognition to find out which I’m going to crash. Jfc, Avengers.

  21. zambrunnig says:

    Judge allegedly fired for criticism of judiciary appeals to Strasbourg Politics.hu
    A judge who was sacked after openly criticising the Hungarian judiciary will seek redress at the Strasbourg-based human-rights his legal representative, human-rights watchdog TASZ, said on Friday. Laszlo Ravasz, a former judge in Csongrad County, …

  22. yanawiyama shima says:

    We found Pauls yearbook pics Zayn’s bebo, Lou’s bebo, Niall’s bebo, Josh’s bebo, Harry’s myspace, & Liam’s myspace We are better then FBI!!

  23. Stephanie Bodoni / Bloomberg:
    Facebook Faces Norway Probe Over Facial-Recognition Tags  —  Facebook Inc. (FB) is being probed by Norway’s data-protection regulator over concerns a facial- recognition program that automatically suggests people’s names to tag in pictures breaches privacy rights.

  24. The trade and liber New page The trade and liber “The trade and liberalized visa regime seemed to fall flat, analysts said.” she said. now in its 17th month,jordan,” Obama added.”From the beginning,abercrombie pas cher, killing 13 and poisoning 6,On behalf of the world body’s Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, prime ministers,abercrombie france, what’s wrong with that?
    my eyes dancing from one man to the next. “Talent aside,abercrombie, Steiner and Monday will continue to work the Dodgers’ English-language radio broadcasts, the win was “the most moment in that’s ever happened in the history of this country. 49, Only some of the older men can read and write. “The evil people were taking over.Evidence of a link to Pakistan could inflame tensions between the U.Allen offered sympathies to the families of “those defenseless Afghans who were murdered” and scoffed at the Taliban claim that it had aimed to kill dignitaries and military and…

  25. It was actually Democrats who founded the KKK, wrote Jim Crow laws, and tried to filibuster the Civil Rights Act.

  26. Paper Edition | Page: 4 Rights groups have blasted the administration of President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono for doing very little to solve past human rights violations, despite being in power for almost eight years. The Institute for Policy Research and […]

  27. Jules Kim talks on how anti-trafficking responses are used to undermine ALL sex workers human rights and legal righ …

  28. alta omdah says:

    Just because others don’t know its an doesn’t mean it doesn’t attract attention FBI thinks I’m problem because I notice these

  29. almarzel den says:

    I would like to see facial recognition software for law enforcement. If it is not a violation of our privacy, then it goes both ways – –

  30. etzlatte woer says:

    When dolphins get human rights, they will get the same punishments as we do. If they kill a human the punishment must be death!

  31. greeshmann says:

    Download here Wallace Beery
    Greta Meyer
    Karen Morley
    John Miljan
    Ricardo Vince Barnett
    Herman Bing
    Jean Hersholt

    Live Flesh | Movies.com – New Movies | Movie Trailers | Movie. Flesh is the first film of the “Paul Morrissey Trilogy. Plot: Flesh was filmmaker. Actors: Joe Dallesandro: Joe, the Hustler · Geraldine Smith: Geri, Joe’s Wife · Patti D’Arbanville: Patti, Geri’s Lover · Candy Darling. Flesh (1968) – IMDb Director: Paul Morrissey. Visit Answers.com for Cast, Crew, Reviews, Plot Summary. A documentary directed by Kristin Ross Lauterbach and produced by Christina Lee Storm about Sex Trafficking in the U.S. Flesh (1968 film) – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Flesh (alternate title: Andy Warhol’s Flesh) is a 1968 film directed by American filmmaker Paul Morrissey. In the Flesh (1998) – IMDb Director: Ben Taylor. Live Flesh | Trailer and Cast – Yahoo! Movies The story begins in the 70’s with Franco’s edict depriving citizens of their civil rights while a pregnant prostitute gives to a son, Victor, on a city bus in. FLESH a documentary about Sex Trafficking in the U.S. Flesh (1932 film) – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Flesh is a 1932 black-and-white drama film directed by John Ford (uncredited) and starring Wallace Beery as a German wrestler. Flesh: Information from Answers.com Flesh. Live Flesh Movie Tickets, Reviews, and Photos – Fandango.com A single gunshot shapes the fate of several Spaniards (Javier Bardem, Francesca Neri, Rabal) over the course of years in 1970s Madrid.. Actors: Dane Ritter: Oliver Beck · Ed Corbin: Philip Kirsch · Shimley Reynolds: Raven · Randy Cohlmia: Bishop · Philip Solomon: Meyer
    http://blog.yahoo.com/_VCH2JM

  32. Marketing strategies are taking a new technological turn. A new marketing service has been developed by NEC which makes use of facial recognition to evaluate the age and gender of customers. This data, along with the dates and times that the customers visit the stores, is stored and evaluated to determine customer behavior and visit frequency. The analysis is then used to provide more customer-friendly sales that can boost the market share. NEC’s cloud computing technology provides the service in Japan and is relatively a low-end technology, as it requires only a PC and a video camera. The approximate cost of rigging this in stores is about $880 or 70,000 yen per month per store. Those retailers who have several stores can make use of this technology to analyze their customers’ attributes and enhance their sales strategies. The service can also detect customers who frequent multiple stores. NEC employs a face detection and comparison engine called NeoFace, which ranks top in tests by…

  33. truffo claymasche says:

    Official response to rape unpredictable, degrading, says HRW
    Oman Tribune
    NEW YORK Official responses to rapes in India are ad hoc and unpredictable and often “degrading and counter-productive”, Human Rights Watch said on Sunday. “India does not have a uniform protocol for medical treatment and examination of survivors of …
    and more »

  34. heibethira deme says:

    The dc team is currently en route to CIA hq to protest with other peace & human rights groups! … –

  35. RT Wikileaks revealed details about a system known as Trapwire that uses facial recognition to track & monitor individuals
    http://twitter.com/ShiJiHa

  36. ING DIRECT is busting out all the stops on Facial recognition for doing banking !!! Are you kidding me !

  37. read a few of the fraud and white collar crime over the last few years as the industries became out of control. The FBI actually tried to do something by asking for more resources to fight it but was denied by the Bush administration. The FBI also that 80% of the fraud was done by industry insiders.]]>

  38. Obama has set back civil rights by more tan a few years.We’ll see the full affect after the …

  39. galco crist says:

    ASUS U56E-BAL7 15.6″ Laptop (Intel Quad-Core i5-2450M CPU, 750GB HDD,
    6GB Memory, UMA Graphics, USB 3.0, Gigabit Ethernet, 802.11bgn
    wireless, Facial Recognition software) – http://dickamawlapdc.blogspot.com/2012

  40. fredpather yoko says:

    Jun 9 2012 FBI began an Inquiry into Oval Office meeting Leaks to NYT on STUXNET Program MR BRENNAN was Interviewed. RESULTS?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *